Governing the Resource: Scarcity-Induced Institutional Change
نویسندگان
چکیده
We provide a dynamic model of natural resource management where the optimal institutional structure that governs resource use changes with resource depletion. Copeland and Taylor (2009) analyze how characteristics of a natural resource determine whether its steady-state management regime is open access, communal property, or private property. We extend this and other studies of endogenous institutions to analyze how and when resource governance may change in transition to the steady state, taking into account the fixed costs of institutional change and the variable costs of enforcement and governance. Assuming that governance cost is increasing in the difference between open-access and the actual harvest, we show that open access can be optimal if the resource is abundant relative to its demand and/or if governance costs are high. Once open access is rendered inefficient due to increased resource scarcity, further depletion warrants institutional change. In the face of set-up costs, optimal governance implies non-monotonic resource dynamics. These findings help to explain the co-evolution of resource scarcity and property rights—from open access to common property and beyond. We also extend the Demsetz/Copeland-Taylor theory of price-induced institutional change to include changing scarcity during the transition to the steady state. JEL Codes: D23, O13, Q20 * Roumasset: Department of Economics, University of Hawaii at Manoa, [email protected]; Tarui: Department of Economics, University of Hawaii at Manoa, [email protected].
منابع مشابه
Evolution of Common Resource Tenure and Governing: Evidence from Pastureland in Mongolia Plateau
Land tenure is to define who hold the land as well as the relationship between tenant and the lord. Most fundamentally tenure and changing tenure is capturing the value of the resource. The nature of the resource and changing relative scarcity are essential to induce or lead evolution of land tenure. Pasture resources have been held in open access and communal tenure for much of the long histor...
متن کاملOil dependence, institutional quality and economic growth: A panel vector autoregression approach
Resources are the foundation of economic growth. With speedy economic and population growth, economic growth is facing a scarcity of resources worldwide. Resource-economy co-ordination has become every government’s main focus in reaching strategic development goals in countries that are on the path of rapid economic development. Sustainable economic development in a country requires resources a...
متن کاملThe Impact Of Institutional Quality On Relation Between Resource Abundance And Economic Growth
متن کامل
Institutional Quality, Natural Resource Rent, and Shadow Economy
Natural resource rent affects countries’ economies through various channels. Revenues from the natural resources sales are expected to boost countries' economic growth, but the economic experience of recent decades reveals the numerous economic problems in these countries, the most important of which may be the increase in the shadow economy size. Moreover, the institutions specify the signific...
متن کاملInstitutional Quality and Curse Resources: An Experimental Study on OPEC Countries
This paper is to study the resource curse applying annual data from 2002 to 2016 for the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) members i.e. Algeria, Iran, Kuwait, Nigeria, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Venezuela. For this purpose, there were concerned the interactions role of resource abundance and institution quality, and their marginal effect of the countrie...
متن کامل